Today, TechFreedom released a coalition letter urging the Senate Commerce Committee to delay voting on the nomination of Danielle Thumann Severs to the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) until she has demonstrated her willingness to defend the First Amendment and a clear understanding of the limits to the FCC’s power over journalism—and until the President renominates Democratic Commissioner Anna Gomez or another Democrat recommended by Senate Democratic leadership so that both nominees can be considered together. More than 25 former senior FCC leaders, scholars of First Amendment, communications, and technology law, and prominent civil liberties organizations joined our letter.

“The FCC has become exactly what Congress tried to avoid a century ago: a political weapon against speech disfavored by the administration,” warned Berin Szóka, President of TechFreedom. Last year, Sen. Ted Cruz, Chair of the Commerce Committee, compared FCC Chair Brendan Carr to a “mafioso … right out of Goodfellas” after Carr threatened Disney with the loss of ABC’s licenses if the company did not fire comedian Jimmy Kimmel, saying “we can do this the easy way or the hard way.” Carr has since only escalated his attacks on ABC and other broadcasters. 

“Chairman Cruz deserves credit for denouncing Carr’s gangster tactics and asking Thumann Severs directly to commit to protect the First Amendment,” continued Szóka. “But her responses at her confirmation hearing were so vague that they left ample room for her to excuse punishing broadcasters for constitutionally protected speech. Indeed, her answers sounded remarkably similar to Carr’s defenses of his tactics. If Cruz truly wants to be remembered for defending the First Amendment, he must get much clearer, more specific answers about how Thumann Severs would apply limits on FCC’s authority required by the First Amendment.” 

Cruz asked Thumann Severs whether she would oppose “using the FCC’s authority to pressure or punish a broadcaster for protected speech?” She said she would do so yet repeatedly declined to explain her understanding of how the public interest obligations and First Amendment rights of broadcasters can coexist. She also said that a decision to revoke broadcasters’ licenses “should [not] be made purely based on someone’s discontent with the content that’s being aired”—thus implying that the President’s anger could be part of such a decision.

“The Senate has a constitutional duty to scrutinize the President’s nominees, and thus has every right to insist that the President nominate at least one Democrat to the Commission before voting on Thumann Severs’ nomination,” concluded Szóka. “Gomez’s term has already expired, so if she isn’t reconfirmed, she’ll have to leave the Commission automatically at the end of this Congress. Stacking the Commission with Republicans while letting the sole Democrat disappear would break with a longstanding tradition of maintaining bipartisan representation on the Commission. Minority Commissioners have always been vital guardians against the abuse of the FCC by both parties. If Senate Republicans rush through this nomination without confirming a Democrat, they will bitterly regret it when future Democratic Presidents deny them representation on the Commission. Exactly that may happen in early 2029.”

###

Find this release on our website and share it on Twitter and Bluesky. We can be reached for comment at media@techfreedom.org. Read our related work, including:

About TechFreedom: 

TechFreedom is a nonprofit, nonpartisan technology policy think tank. We work to chart a path forward for policymakers towards a bright future where technology enhances freedom, and freedom enhances technology

</>